WWII German POW returns to say Thanks – Intermission Story (27)

In an Oct. 3, 2017 photo, Günter Gräwe, a German POW held in Washington during World War II, bids farewell as he finishes touring a former barracks with Deputy Joint Base Commander Col. William Percival at Joint Base Lewis-McChord. (Steve Ringman/The Seattle Times via AP)

By HAL BERNTON, Seattle Times

SEATTLE (AP) — Gunter Grawe spent three years as a German prisoner of war in western Washington, a World War II incarceration he recalls not with rancor, but gratitude for the chance to “live and learn in America.”  Grawe always thought about returning to the state to say thank you.

In early October, the rail-thin veteran, now 91, did just that during a brief visit to this base, where guard towers and barbed-wire fences are long gone but some of the two-story wooden barracks that once housed German prisoners still stand.

He declared his capture by the Americans at the age of 18 “his luckiest day,” and reminisced about camp life that included English, French and Spanish classes organized by other POWs and a commissary stocked with chocolate, ice cream and Coca-Cola.

“I never had anything to complain about,” Grawe said. “No guard called us nasty names. I had a better life as a prisoner than my mother and sister back home in Germany.”

In a global conflict that resulted in the deaths of more than 60?million people — including 6?million Jewish Holocaust victims — Grawe was indeed fortunate to live to an old age denied so many others. Grawe was filled with patriotism as he went to serve in the German army but now denounces Adolf Hitler as “one arrogant, hypocritical dammed liar” who led his nation into disaster and shame.

Grawe’s trip to Joint Base Lewis-McChord was arranged with the help of HistoryLink.org, a Seattle-based online encyclopedia that chronicles the state’s past.   “We have a list of those who were pro-Nazi, and he was not on it,” said Duane Denfield, a historian who works as a JBLM contractor.

Grawe’s military career started in Latvia, where he went through training for what appeared to be an assignment to the Eastern Front to fight a resurgent Russian army. If Josef Stalin’s forces had captured him, he likely would have been sent to a labor camp, where harsh conditions killed many.

But then Allied forces invaded France, and the Germans scrambled to try to slow their advance toward Paris with fresh reinforcements.  Grawe was transferred to Normandy, where he served in a tank unit that was quickly overwhelmed by the U.S. and British armies.

“It was a terrible fight in Normandy — it wasn’t what we expected, and we were young and inexperienced,” Grawe said.

Grawe said he realized how well things had turned out as he was put on the ocean liner Queen Mary for the voyage to America. He had comfortable quarters and most important — ample meals — served on metal trays.  Next, he took a train ride across America to what was then Fort Lewis.  At the Army post south of Tacoma, barracks vacated by U.S. troops were turned into prison quarters for some 4,000 German POWs at five locations.

Fort Lewis (now part of the joint base) was part of a much broader POW prison-camp network of some 500 sites across the country that held 400,000 Germans. Overall, historians say these prisoners were treated well. Some Germans even referred to their camp as a “golden cage,” according to Michael Farquhar, who wrote a 1997 article about the POWs for The Washington Post.

German POW’s work on a farm.

 The POWs’ relative comfort angered some wartime Americans who had lost their loved ones to German troops. But they did have to work, providing labor at a time when the massive troop mobilization made it hard to find enough people to bring in the nation’s crops.

Grawe traveled by truck from Fort Lewis to help in apple, sugar-beet and potato harvests.  Later, he was transferred to Arizona to bring in cotton.  He recalled his farm labor as a real adventure that earned him an 80-cents-a-day salary to buy things at the commissary.

Through his years as a prisoner, Grawe says he came to love America.

But his first loyalties were to Germany. As a boy, he participated in Hitler Youth.  He joined the army as what he calls a “young idealistic soldier” who thought it “right to fight for an honest and upright fatherland” just like his father, a plumber turned soldier who died in the war in 1940.

Grawe says he first learned of the horrors of the Nazi concentration camps while a prisoner in America. He initially brushed off the news as propaganda because it was conveyed by a U.S. officer. When he wrote home to his mother and sister, they replied it was true.

In 1947, two years after Germany’s unconditional surrender, Grawe was released.  In the postwar era, as the German economy surged, Grawe prospered.  Through the decades, he returned to the U.S. several times to vacation. But only after his wife died in 2016 did he make up his mind to return to Washington state.

On Oct. 3, a brilliant fall day, Grawe arrived at JBLM. He brought his electric bike, determined to ride the final distance — a little over a mile — to the old camp site. On each side of his bike’s rear wheel hung a sign: “USA, the country and its people, you are my first and final love!”

At the blacktop by the barracks, he looked around somewhat uncertainly. He recalled a barren site. This place was full of fir trees that had grown up in the seven decades since the prisoners had gone home.

Gunter Grawe

He was greeted by the base’s deputy joint commander, Col. William Percival, who offered a handshake, and later a hug inside a building now empty and bare of furniture.

 “You remind us that . how you treat somebody defines who we are,” Percival said. “There are times, even today, when we may want to forget that.  And you let us know that’s a lesson not to be forgotten.”  Grawe then went for lunch at a base dining hall.

He piled his plate full of a noodle casserole, and sat down to eat one more ample meal served up by the U.S. Army. This time, as a free man.

Click on images to enlarge.

####################################################################################

Military Humor – by: Bill Mauldin 

 

####################################################################################

Farewell Salutes – 

Michael Aiello – St. Louis, MO; US Army, WWII, SSgt., KIA

Robert Blakeley – Jacksonville, FL; USMC

Vincent Burns – Athol, MA; US Army Air Corps, WWII, ETO

Richard Cavazos – San Antonio, TX; US Army, Vietnam, BGeneral

Walter Hackenberg – Middleburg, PA; US Army, Korea, POW, KIA

Duane Hackney – Flint, MI; US Air Force, Vietnam, (most decorated airman in U.S. history)

Charlie Laine – Broad Channel, NY; US Navy, WWII

David McElroy – Brookline, MA; US Coast Guard, WWII, Yeoman

William Parham – Bedford, IN; US Navy, WWII, PTO

Jacob Sims – OK & Juneau, AK; US Army, Afghanistan, Chief Warrant Officer, KIA

#####################################################################################

About GP

Everett Smith served with the Headquarters Company, 187th Regiment, 11th A/B Division during WWII. This site is in tribute to my father, "Smitty." GP is a member of the 11th Airborne Association. Member # 4511 and extremely proud of that fact!

Posted on November 6, 2017, in Current News, Home Front, Uncategorized, WWII and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 176 Comments.

  1. What a wonderful story. God bless America.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. This is a great story, GP! Thank you for sharing all sides and perspectives of war with readers. And this one had a happy ending! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Among the horrors a tale of redemption. Most of them were just human. LIke us.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Nice to hear that the US made such a good impression on this prisoner. I liked Percival’s quote: “How you treat somebody defines who we are.”

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Looks like he was better off than what I was living in England on very strict rationing. during the war
    Chocolate was unheard of for us, we received 2 oz per month sweet(candy?) allowance, which gave us a couple of packets of Wrigleys chewing gum, not the sticks that the GI’s had but sugar coated things 4 or 5 in a small packet.

    We would make this last a month by taking it out sticking it on the bedheadt over night.

    This believe it or not was recommended by the “Radio Doctor” who advised parents to do this for their children to keep their jaws working properly. We had very little meat we did get plety of fish though.

    I can’t remember ever eating butter until I came to Australia in1951

    Liked by 2 people

    • My mother used to tell me about the “oleo” they had in a plastic bag with a yellow capsule. You squished the bag to make the stuff look like butter. My dad said he felt sorry for the civilians back home, because the soldiers had so much real butter, they used it to grease their equipment. I suppose one hand didn’t know what the other was doing.

      Liked by 1 person

      • You hit that right on GP. Well it’s over now some of us learnt from it; sadly there are still those who know nothing of the horrors and just think it’s a man thing to go out killing ‘lesser ‘ mortals. 😦

        Like

  6. Thanks for another great story- it is always nice to hear a positive one 🙂 I’ve been to JBLM but had never heard much of the history or about housing POWs- interesting!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. In war, only “brutality” is conspicuous.
    We ordinary citizens, originally, not hate each other.
    Strategy of Crazy top or Crafty moneymaking, citizens are thrown into the battlefield.
    We have ” human mind”, so we want to value such nice these stories.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Wonderful story, G. And it reminds me that our nation can be great. –Curt

    Liked by 1 person

  9. It’s a lovely story and I appreciate his gratitude, but don’t quite understand how the prisoners were fed so well when the US was issuing ration cards for food.

    Like

    • Perhaps for them, what the ordinary person in the US ate really was terrific for the prisoners. Latvia wasn’t the richest country and the Germans didn’t have as much as we did. Then of course you have politics involved….

      Liked by 1 person

  10. EVERY BODY should read this.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Wonderful. Love Perceval’s words, too.

    Liked by 1 person

  12. “Wow” is the only word Of I can think of to say about your post.

    Liked by 1 person

  13. 91 jaar is niet niets en mooi dat hij na al die tijd nog dankbaar is

    Like

  14. Interesting, GP. Thanks. Does this mean you are up and running again?

    Liked by 1 person

  15. With your focus on international understanding and reconciliation your post on a German POW has been another heart-warming account of how human beings should be treated. I also had a relative back in Germany, who reported fair treatment as a POW in an American camp. Thank you for another great post, GP!

    Liked by 2 people

  16. A young man caught in the middle of a world gone mad. Fortunately, he was lucky enough to see America for what it is and can be. In return, he has indeed shown how grateful one can be for having been given that chance. That’s why this country is a symbol of hope.

    Liked by 2 people

  17. Another great article! What that must have been like for Grawe after all those years! I’m also going to give a shout-out to the Bill Mauldin cartoons. I have some of his books 🙂

    Liked by 3 people

  18. The same thing as at Camp Concordia also happened in England where the more fanatical Nazis killed a nice prisoner because he wouldn’t join in with their plans for an uprising. Herr Grawe shows us all the way forward though. Peace on earth and goodwill to all men.

    Liked by 2 people

  19. Thanks for sharing this sweet story. Aww, the last two sentences 🙏🏽.

    Liked by 1 person

  20. What fine account. Outstanding post, GP.

    Liked by 2 people

  21. As always them cartoons nail it better than entire books~!

    Liked by 1 person

  22. Just a wonderful story.

    Liked by 1 person

  23. There’s a book about German POW’s, that ended up in Camp Concordia in Kansas. It was an interesting read. It wasn’t all violins and roses, either. There was an uprising of prisoners, that were still loyal Nazis. They killed one of their own fellow Germans, they felt was too chummy with his American captors.

    Liked by 1 person

  24. Hello! Thank you for this fascinating article. It shows multiple facets that can be easily overlooked–the young German soldier had no idea there were such horrors as concentration camps. And what Maria Holm said, as well.

    Liked by 1 person

  25. Hat’s off!! Lovely article GP.

    Liked by 1 person

  26. Thanks for that very interesting and enlightening article.

    Liked by 1 person

  27. Heart-warming article. I am proud of America for being so visionary despite current conditions.

    Liked by 2 people

  28. Sweet story but one that made me wince at times. Although I am proud that our country treated its prisoners so well, I can’t help but feel pained, thinking of this man taking French lessons and eating well and having a good time while his fellow Nazis were torturing and massacring people in concentration camps. That he now sees that Hitler was arrogant and a liar is not enough. I don’t sense any real remorse for what his country did, only regret that they elected an arrogant liar. Hitler was far more than that—he was a totally evil man, probably the most Satanic human being who ever walked the earth.

    Liked by 3 people

    • I can understand your feelings on his words. Being as Germany lost WWI, Hitler capitalized on the lost feelings of the people and had to locate one common enemy for them to rally behind him. It works on the same principle as ‘mob mentality’. For FDR to help his friend Churchill and cover up the exorbitant amount of Lend Lease he had sent without permission, FDR had to create a situation for the majority of people to give up isolationism and rally ’round him. It worked in both cases. Very sad indeed, actually, no words to describe.

      Like

      • I understand how Hitler managed to get support in post-WWI Germany, but this man was talking many years later when the worst he could say about Hitler was that he was an arrogant liar. That, to me, was the least of Hitler’s sins. And I don’t think we can in any way equate FDR to Hitler, can we?

        Liked by 2 people

  29. Too many people today like to make off-the-cuff comparisons of some in the U.S. to Nazis or other such evil characters, and while we certainly do have our idiots like Skinheads, BLM and Antifa thugs, there is no real comparison. Stories such as this just go to show how often Americans really are the good guys in some pretty horrible situations. Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 3 people

  30. Love the Bill Mauldin cartoons. As a child during WW II, the daily cartoon was the first thing I looked for in the newspaper.

    Liked by 2 people

  31. Gunter’s capture by the Americans was indeed his luckiest day. Living as a POW in better conditions than many of his family at home is something sobering to consider. The fact that he was a Latvian serving in the German Army would undoubtedly have resulted in his execution, if he had been captured by the Soviets.
    Best wishes, Pete.

    Liked by 3 people

  32. Interesting, heart-warming story.
    I live a couple of small towns away from a base that was used as a German internment camp.
    Different family members that have lived in and around the area have told fascinating stories (unfortunately, I was too young to understand or realize the significance of the stories, and most of the family members have long passed away.)
    You can still see where the fences, topped with barb wire, line the road, rusting and grown into the tree lines. A stark reminder of a very different era.

    Liked by 2 people

  33. How nice to see you “back”! And what a touching story you’ve brought. It’s a reminder that we never can predict the consequences of our actions, and that even the smallest gestures of kindness can reap great rewards. Not only that, who wouldn’t be taken with that photo of Mr. Grawe with his bicycle? When I saw it, I thought, “I want to be him at that age!”

    Liked by 2 people

  34. Better picking cotton than being picked off in a tank! A lovely story and how true those words of Col. William Percival.

    Liked by 2 people

  35. A great story! My dad grew up on a ranch near Wheatland, Wyoming, and he told me that there was a German POW camp nearby. He would go there sometimes and talk with the prisoners through the wire. He was surprised to learn that they were ordinary people just like him. He also said that security was very lax – after all, where could they go if they escaped.

    Liked by 2 people

  36. This was a pleasure to read.

    Liked by 2 people

  37. Your blog has been my daily ‘go-to’ in filling the huge knowledge void re: the PTO – your recent posts on the Burma fighting especially (my father was a Polish POW of the Germans for the War’s duration).
    Q: I always assumed that your ‘farewell salute’ section was for veterans who recently passed.
    I wanted to learn more about Air Force Sgt Duane Hackney, as ‘most decorated’.
    His Wiki indicated he died in ’93 – glad you listed him in any case so his heroism could be shared. Are entries in your regular listings not limited to recent Veteran deaths?

    Liked by 2 people

    • The Farewell Salutes are for any member of the military (on the Allied side). I knew I did not have Sgt. Hackney listed prior to this and wished to correct my oversight. You will also see soldiers who were KIA during WWII, Korea and Vietnam, that probably means their remains were located and identified and were finally coming home for burial. I thank you for making Pacific Paratrooper your ‘go-to’ spot for the PTO!!

      Like

  38. Of interest to me is why 400,000 were shipped across the Atlantic to be held by USA mainland and who initiated that? And then there is the consternation and anecdotes that they were treated better than the USA’s own black soldiers.

    Liked by 2 people

    • They were shipped here because the UK asked us to. We weren’t prepared for such a scenario, but the UK was having a housing shortage. As for our own black soldiers, Carl, I couldn’t say. It was a different world back then or the Germans had a Geneva Convention agreement protecting them? I don’t know.

      Like

  39. Great article GP, good to hear these stories.

    Liked by 2 people

  40. Reblogged this on PenneyVanderbilt and commented:
    Great Story!

    Liked by 2 people

  41. Thank you so much for sharing this story. I plan on using the quote by Col Percival as he meet Herr Grawe “You remind us that how you treat somebody defines who we are,”
    in a post tomorrow I’ll be writing about having finished reading the tale, The Book Thieves—the story of the millions of books plundered from all of Europe and the USSR by the Nazis–the quote reminds us that we are more than soldiers, enemies, prisoners, victims—we are human beings first—-
    a very timely message……

    Liked by 2 people

  42. Wonderful Story. M 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  43. Lovely story of gratitude and how it pays to treat people desently. The truth always comes up to the surface

    Liked by 3 people

  44. This is a testament to the importance of behaving in humane ways.

    Liked by 6 people

  45. That’s interesting. Yes, Grawe was certainly a lucky guy – so much luckier than the millions who died, and the millions more who suffered loss, in this most dreadful conflict. We hear a lot about our lads imprisoned in mainland Europe or the Far East, but the stories of ex-enemy POWs are fascinating – I don’t know about the US, but many stayed in the UK after the war.

    Liked by 3 people

    • I’m sure they were in the UK, much closer than the US, that’s for sure. Being as I concentrate on the pacific War, the Intermission time gives me a chance to insert stories like this.

      Like

  46. I’ve often wondered what happened to some of these guys. Very interesting article. Thank you.

    Liked by 2 people

  47. Thank you very much.

    Like

  1. Pingback: Mortal enemy « cookiecrumbstoliveby

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.