Korean War (12)
MacArthur’s twice rejected appeal to bring Chiang’s troops in from Taiwan was sent out again. Washington responded that the idea was being considered, but would involve political and diplomatic consequences. The British were calling for a multi-national committee to run the war, but in answer to that, General Omar Bradley retorted that no war could be directed by a committee.
30 November 1950, Truman held a press conference that ultimately turned into a discussion about using the atomic bomb. When asked by Frank Bourgholtzer of NBC, “Does this mean that we would not use the atomic bomb except on a United Nations’ authorization?” Truman replied, “The action against Communist China depends on the action of the UN. The military commander in the field will have charge of the use of weapons, as he always has…” (Truman, forgetting the rules of the Atomic Energy Act, had in fact handed the use of the A-bomb over to MacArthur.) This news immediately shot around the world.
General Marshall knew that Prime Minister Atlee would panic at the subject of the Bomb and sure enough, he was on is way to the U.S. Atlee, who had praised MacArthur on the Inchon invasion was now concerned with protecting British international trade and its colonies. MacArthur only wanted the weapon to be stored on Okinawa in the event it would be imperative to use to withdraw the troops safely out of Korea. (The threat of the Bomb, by the end of December, would come mainly from Washington.)
The 10,000 men of the 1st Marine Division, about 2,000 G.I.s and a small unit of the British Royal Marine Commandos were also threatened to be entrapped at their location. The massive battle of the Chosin Reservoir, destined to become the most famous battle of the war, began on 1 December. With the foresight of their commander, General O.P. Smith, having had moved gingerly before the CCF attack, had stockpiled supplies along the route from Hungnam. The Chinese forces were running low on supplies and becoming exhausted. MacArthur felt that General Walker had lost control of his troops; if he had made a stand above Pyongyang, the war would have gone differently.
The British General Mansergh sent a dispatch to London: American soldiers are not interested in the Korean civil war, their morale is bad and they are untrained for defense. They only joined in peacetime so as to receive a G.I. Bill education after discharge.
While leadership was being blamed for any defeat or retreat, a Silver Star sergeant was pulling off his mittens to hurl a hand grenade and got frostbitten fingers for his effort; Navy Lt.Commander Lessenden, running a Marine hospital tent, reported that plasma bottles were freezing and breaking; Corpsman Pfc Win Scott was holding morphine Syrettes in his mouth to keep them from freezing and soldiers were sleeping with their rifles to keep them operational. The Chinese were also dealing with the gruesome weather: Sgt. Ray Davis brought his colonel to see an enemy outpost – all but 2 men were frozen to death.
The long march south from Hagaru to Koto-ri, to be followed by Hungnam, began 6 December. To dispose of surplus ordnance, they shelled the Chinese during the night. Captain Drake and his 31st Tank Company were among the last units out of Hagaru and the town was set on fire as they saw the enemy scrounge the streets in search of food. The rear guard blew the bridge over Changjun River to slow the CCF from following. The road down was still a dangerous trek of icy, twisting turns causing trucks and tanks to slide down. The Chinese still lay in ambush, but the exhausted Allies continued to fight. The CCF blew a 16′ gap in a bridge known as Funchilin Pass, but the American engineers built a steel span from materials dropped by parachute.
MSgt. Thomas Brett, US Army 3rd Division said, “Cold chills still go up my spine as I recall watching Marines, themselves frozen from head to foot, meticulously caring for their wounded and bringing back the dead bodies of their comrades…”
6 December, MacArthur issued the CINCFE (Commander-in-chief, Far East) Plan No. 203 that was 38 pages detailing ‘the orderly withdrawal” of all UN forces and equipment from Korea to Japan. This would also include the ROKs and POWs, “due to pressure from superior forces.”
Both General Almond and Walker acted as though everything they destroyed – MacArthur could replace. General O.P. Smith argued the point on the destruction of good materiel and Almond told him, “Don’t worry about your equipment, once you get back we’ll replace it all.” Smith responded, “I’m not going to do that. This is the equipment we fight with.” When Almond flew out, Smith told his operations officer, “This guy is a maniac. He’s nuts. I can’t believe he’s saying these things.”
Click on images to enlarge.
######################################################################################
Nathaniel Young – Fairfax, VA & Tallahassee, FL; US Army Air Corps, WWII ETO 8th AF co-pilot, 35 combat missions + D-Day
Kenneth Condit – NYC, NY & Princeton, NJ; US Army, WWII
Frances Stueve – Dyerville, Iowa & Washington DC; survivor of Pearl Harbor
William A. Bennett – Fort Pierce & Gainsville, FL; US Navy, WWII aircraft communications instructor, graduate of Annapolis
Charles F. Milheron – Bangor, ME; US Army, Korean War
John Fallat – Dickson City, PA & Alexandria, VA; US Navy, Korean War
Dennis Reinke – Arlington, VA; US Navy, 26 year veteran, Master Chief Petty Officer
#######################################################################################
Resources: armchairgeneral.com; olivedrab.com; “Korean War” by Stephen Badsey; “Warfare of the 20th Century” by Christopher Chant; Army archives; “MacArthur’s War” by Stanley Weintraub & “Hey Mac, Where Ya Been?” by Henry Berry
Posted on September 13, 2013, in Korean War and tagged family history, History, Korea, Korean War, MacArthur, Military, Military History, nostalgia, Pacific War, veterans. Bookmark the permalink. 40 Comments.
gpcox – I never realized that cold weather could be such a threat to the forces in Korea. It made me think of Valley Forge.
LikeLike
I can’t say first-hand, but by their records – it looks worse than Valley Forge. If you get to see M*A*S*H* re-runs, they didn’t exaggerated.
LikeLike
thanks for stopping by 🙂
LikeLike
I admit to feeling more and more depressed with these posts. So many soldiers tearing each other apart, so many civilians, their lives gone. Casual sentences like ‘…and the town was set on fire…’. Now we watch this nightly on TV from Syria. Like others I am ashamed at how little note I took of the Korean war. I am almost ashamed to belong to the human race, seeing what we did and are still doing to one another.
LikeLike
Unfortunately, I have to agree. We simply do not fit into the Nature of this planet.
LikeLike
Another well-done entry. Thanks for bringing so much to light that we should not forget.
LikeLike
I’ll keep on trying, some parts of the war even the book authors didn’t want to bother with – but I promise to continue digging.
LikeLike
So easy for the pundits who make war happen, to sit back and deliver their ultimatums, but quite another to face the conditions their decisions have forced other into suffering.
LikeLike
I know, I’ve been saying that since I was a kid. If the politicians have the argument, let them do the fighting. I was taught to fight my own battles.
LikeLike
Like we discussed in the earlier post, if Truman hadn’t been timid earlier and had US troops up front, near the Yalu, the Chinese would not have jumped in. They only did so, because they knew they’d be attacking weaker ROK forces first, and then wade into ours further south with momentum on their side. German Panzers, Soviet Shock troops, Patton’s Third Army, all showed before Korea that lightning momentum is half the victory in any offensive. The CCF offensive, had a lot of similarities to Stalingrad in that the Soviets did not break through German line to encircle the 6th Army, they broke through weaker Romanian, Italian, Hungarian troops which were protecting 6th Army’s flanks.
LikeLike
Well put, Kevin. Great explanation to put my posts in perspective, thanks.
LikeLike
My goodness…I shake my head in astonishment. And the poor soldiers and doctors; such cold and terrible conditions they endured.
LikeLike
It seems impossible, with military gear, to have survived those conditions.
LikeLike
Thanks, I admire your words and welcome learning about a war that sometimes is forgotten 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you, I appreciate you saying so.
LikeLike
So many strange happenings behind the scenes. I have to wonder where I was when all of this was taking place that I heard so little about it. Thanks for the enlightenment.
LikeLike
Our parents were letting us live like kids.
LikeLike
Easy enough to be such a maniac, no?
Which is why the guys wanting a war should always be in the front lines, enjoying their lovely war. Front lines, I said …
LikeLike
Even as a child I felt if the politicians wanted to fight – let them. Leave the rest of us out of it.
LikeLike
More surprising news in this post. Threatening to use the A Bomb again, really? Interesting note by the Brits about the American morale being low and the GIs only signing up because of the GI bill.
LikeLike
Honestly, he was more and likely being accurate. Supposedly we had 5 years of peace and who knew anything about Korea and a civil war?
LikeLike
Would be good if some people who are talking war could read your blog. How soon they forget.
LikeLike
Anything to stop yet another war!
LikeLike
Gen. MacArther is THE hero in my book, as a person who was born and raised in Korea, South Korea that is, and old enough to know he saved us twice, once from the hands of Imperial Japan and again from the communist party up north.. Thanks for the great read!
LikeLike
My pleasure. Maybe you can enlighten some of us about South Korean history as it relates here.
LikeLike
oh.. i’m not even qualified to teach anybody about history.. lol
LikeLike
You’d probably be surprised once you got started.
LikeLike
“When Almond flew out, Smith told his operations officer, “This guy is a maniac. He’s nuts. I can’t believe he’s saying these things”…Seems this could apply to a number of the leadership on all sides. What appaling conditions for the soldiers. Thanks for reminding us about this terrible struggle.
LikeLike
As I’ve said before, I believe Almond was a yes man and every war has at least one.
LikeLike
I can’t even begin to imagine the Hell these soldiers went through. My opinion of General Almond continues to sink lower and lower.
LikeLike
As far as I can tell, he was a yes man. (every war has at least one)
LikeLike
Great story thank you for sharing. Ann
LikeLike
My pleasure, good to hear from you.
LikeLike
I have less respect for Truman after reading this. Not that I was overly impressed before now.
LikeLike
I know what you mean. I never really thought about him one way or the other until the research.
LikeLike
How can history forget this war?
LikeLike
Not only forget it, but have the gall (at the time) to say with a straight face that it is a police action!?!
LikeLike
Sometimes we have to look at what we sacrificed to understand who we are. These are the stories of the forgotten heroes who fought for the better good and to further democracy. Do you think MacArthur ever really considered using the A-bomb? What are your thoughts?
LikeLike
With all I’ve read, I would say NO. I think he just wanted to hold it over their heads. Thanks for taking an interest.
LikeLike
Pingback: KOREAN WAR Was A Sham | ELLIOT LAKE News